Local guide · ParadiseSpearfishing in Paradise: spots, seasons and rules
Updated 2026-09-04 · By Oleksandr, spearfisher
Whitefish Point Underwater Preserve is Lake Superior at its best: visibility from 6 to 45 m and wrecks largely free of zebra and quagga mussels, which is rare on the Great Lakes. The shallow sand-shelf sites west of the point sit beside a deep technical band, and the Great Lakes Shipwreck Museum stands on the point itself. Under the 2026 rules this is inside the Lake Superior underwater-spear water: the game fish are open, minus Stannard Rock, Big Reef, Isle Royale and Pictured Rocks National Lakeshore. Freedive only, daylight only, and a free underwater spearfishing licence on top of the fishing licence, with no monthly reporting since the 2026 season.
TL;DR
- Whitefish Point Underwater Preserve is Lake Superior at its best: visibility from 6 to 45 m and wrecks largely free of zebra and quagga mussels, which is rare on the Great Lakes.
- The 2026 regulations opened Michigan's Lake Superior water — the MI/WI border east to the St. Marys River — so lake trout, northern pike and walleye are open here, with Stannard Rock, Big Reef and the 4.5-mile ring round Isle Royale cut out of it.
- Two licences: the All Species fishing licence plus a free but mandatory underwater spearfishing licence with no monthly reporting since the 2026 season. Freedive only, daylight only, spear fired submerged on a line of 20 ft or less.
- Marks worth the trip: Jupiter and Allegheny, Alec Nimick, M. M. Drake, with depths from a snorkel to 14–17 m. Bays and harbours freeze from January to March.
Where are the dive and hunting spots near Paradise (Whitefish Point)?
Depths below are the published site depths, not a promise about conditions. Outside the buoyed preserve sites you find the mark yourself.
| Spot | Type | Depth | Level | Access | Notes |
|---|
| Jupiter and Allegheny | Wreck pair | 3–9 m | Beginner, snorkel-friendly | Boat or long swim, close inshore | Two wrecks on the same position west of Whitefish Point, in sand. Timbers and ironwork appear and disappear with the sand year to year; shallow and bright on a calm day. |
| Alec Nimick | Wreck | 8 m | Beginner to intermediate | Boat, off Vermilion | The 1907 Alec Nimick off Vermilion, alternately buried and uncovered by shifting sand. This is the water that runs 6 to 45 m of visibility, with almost no mussel growth on the hull. |
| M. M. Drake | Wreck | 12–15 m | Intermediate | Boat, open water | Wooden steamer foundered off Vermilion Point in the 1901 gale and located in 1978. Machinery and hull sections on sand — a moderate-depth open-water dive for a settled day. |
| Myron | Wreck | 14–17 m | Intermediate to advanced | Boat, open Superior | The lumber hooker Myron, lost with seventeen hands in the 1919 gale and now scattered north of Whitefish Point. A boat dive in open Superior; cold year-round and worth a redundant gas plan. |
Is spearfishing allowed in Paradise (Whitefish Point)?
Yes, within limits. Michigan's 2026 underwater-spear waters are named lake by lake: Lake Michigan from the MI/IN border to the 45th parallel, a 2-mile strip in Green Bay to the Ford River mouth, a 5-mile strip from Point Detour to the Brevort River, Lake Huron from the Thunder Bay River pier at Alpena south to Fort Gratiot Light, Lake Erie to the Celeron Island line, and Lake Superior to the St. Marys River — with Grand Traverse Bay, Stannard Rock, Big Reef and the 4.5-mile ring round Isle Royale cut out of them. The 2026 regulations opened Michigan's Lake Superior water — the MI/WI border east to the St. Marys River — so lake trout, northern pike and walleye are open here, with Stannard Rock, Big Reef and the 4.5-mile ring round Isle Royale cut out of it. What stays open is the year-round list, which runs in all Michigan waters except designated trout lakes and streams and the Michigan-Wisconsin boundary waters. The instrument is the Bow & Spear Fishing Regulations table of the Michigan Fishing Guide, a Fisheries Order under NREPA Part 487.
Which fish can you spear at Paradise (Whitefish Point)?
The year-round Michigan list is the backbone: bowfin, bullheads, burbot, common carp, catfish, cisco, freshwater drum, gizzard shad, goldfish, grass carp, longnose gar, rainbow smelt, suckers and lake whitefish. On these lakes whitefish, cisco and burbot are real targets on it, not a consolation prize. Lake sturgeon is off the table: spearing it is prohibited except in a special Black Lake winter season, and on every water here it is closed or release-only. Michigan's table is an enumerating one: trout and salmon other than lake trout, bass, sunfishes and crappie are not named, so they are not open.
What licence and gear does Michigan require?
Two licences, not one. You need the Michigan All Species fishing licence — 26 USD resident, 76 USD non-resident, 10 USD a day, from age 17 — plus a free annual underwater spearfishing licence, which is mandatory — though its monthly effort-and-harvest report was abolished for the 2026 season. The gear rules are just as concrete. A rubber- or spring-propelled spear may be fired only while you are fully submerged, and it must be tethered to a line no longer than 20 ft. Scuba and rebreathers are prohibited while underwater spearfishing, so this is a freedive discipline. Daylight only, bands unloaded whenever you move between areas, and 150 ft off swimming areas, docks, boat access sites and power intakes — which effectively closes harbour mouths.
What do the preserve and sanctuary rules mean for you?
Whitefish Point Underwater Preserve is a bottomland preserve created under NREPA Part 761 (MCL 324.76101 et seq.). What it protects is abandoned property and artifacts on Great Lakes bottomlands — no fishing or spearing prohibition was located in it. The practical rule is the one every local charter states anyway: take nothing off a wreck, and dive the buoys where they exist.
When is the season and what is the water like at Paradise (Whitefish Point)?
Bays and harbours freeze from January to March. The dive season runs from late May to October and peaks in August and September; the surface rarely passes 13-15 °C and below 15 m the water sits at 4-7 °C all year round. Plan for a thick suit with hood, gloves and boots, or a drysuit: the thermocline shapes every dive here, and what feels workable at the surface is a different lake ten metres down. There is no tide on the Great Lakes — the level moves with wind and pressure.
What are the safety risks at Paradise (Whitefish Point)?
Cold is the first risk and it is not seasonal: below the thermocline the water stays a few degrees above freezing all summer, and the freedive-only rule leaves you no gas reserve to buy time with. The second is exposure. Most of these sites sit in open lake with no shelter and, outside the buoyed preserves, no mooring at all, so weather windows are short and a shot line is your own responsibility. Finally, ice: the water freezes for months, and frazil and shore ice make the shoulder seasons a different sport.
FAQ
Can you spear walleye or pike at Paradise (Whitefish Point)?
Yes. Under the 2026 rules this is inside the Lake Superior underwater-spear water: the game fish are open, minus Stannard Rock, Big Reef, Isle Royale and Pictured Rocks National Lakeshore. The year-round list stays open on top of them.
Can you use scuba for spearfishing in Michigan?
No. Scuba, rebreathers and similar devices are prohibited while underwater spearfishing: Michigan is freedive-only.
What licence do you need?
The Michigan All Species fishing licence plus a free annual underwater spearfishing licence, whose mandatory monthly effort-and-harvest report was abolished for the 2026 season.
Can you spear at night?
No. It is prohibited from 30 minutes after sunset to 30 minutes before sunrise, and you must stay 150 ft off swimming areas, docks, ramps and power intakes.
Are the wrecks buoyed?
It depends. Where charters or the preserve organisation buoy sites, they do it for the season only; elsewhere there is no mooring and you bring your own shot line.
When is the best time to dive Paradise (Whitefish Point)?
Bays and harbours freeze from January to March.
Portugal
Spain